SC Ruling: No Bail Restrictions If Grounds Of Arrest Are Not Given

Alankar Mishra

Author

Updated: 16-04-2025 at 12:38 PM

The Supreme Court of India has determined that any arrest conducted without prior information to the accused regarding the reason for arrest is a violation of Article 22(1) of the Constitution. An arrest carried out in this manner will be declared invalid. As per the given ruling, such an arrest goes against the Constitution and does not bail for the accused, irrespective of a chargesheet being filed or the trial court already cognizant.

This verdict was given in the case of Vihaan Kumar vs. State of Haryana and in this case, Justices Abhay S Oka and N Kotishwar Singh emphasised the fact that a person who has been arrested needs to be given details of the charges against him as early as is possible.

Key Highlights

Ruling	Details
Grounds of Arrest Must Be Communicated	The accused must be informed in a language they understand.
The burden of Proof on Investigating Officer	Authorities must prove compliance with Article 22(1).
Violation Renders Arrest Invalid	If not informed, the arrest is unconstitutional and vitiated.
Bail Cannot Be Denied	Courts must release the accused, even if statutory bail restrictions apply.
Magistrate’s Role	Magistrates must ensure compliance with Article 22(1) before granting remand.
Chargesheet or Cognizance Order Not Valid	Filing a chargesheet does not validate an illegal arrest.

Why Is This Ruling Important?

A recent court decision has established a new legal benchmark which defends individual freedom and changes the processes surrounding arrests and bail in India. Here is the significance of this ruling:

Preserves Basic Liberties: Secures the right to individual freedom under Articles 21 and 22 (1).
Restricts Unjust Detention: Guarantees accountable and responsible procedures in arresting people.
Enhances Bail Rights: Enables judges to grant bail even where there are legal limitations.
Shifts Burden to the Investigating Agencies: Compels the police to provide valid grounds for arrests that are legally acceptable.

Supreme Court’s Directives on Article 22(1) Compliance

The Constitution’s Article 22(1) is said to be very valuable, as said by the Supreme Court, as while arresting a suspect, there is due process to be followed that ensures that the suspect’s rights are protected and respected as well. These are the primary instructions of the court:

The suspect should be made aware of the reason behind the arrest straight away.
The authorities are obliged to demonstrate that the information was given in an easily understandable format.
In case of an allegation of non-compliance, the investigating agency has the burden to comply.
In cases of Article 22 violation, the restrictions on legislated bail will not apply and courts will have to take compulsory action of directing the release of the accused.
Magistrates must check proof of observation of the orders before allowing remand.
An unlawful arrest does not affect the validity of the investigation, the charge sheet, or even the trial. These do not constitute an illegal arrest, and those charges can still factually stand.

Justice Singh’s Additional Observations

Justice N Kotishwar Singh highlighted key safeguards for the accused. He stressed the need for transparency in arrests and legal protection for detainees. Here are his key observations:

The grounds of arrest must not only be communicated to the accused but also to their friends, relatives, or nominated persons as per Section 50 of the CrPC.
This ensures that legal action can be taken to challenge the arrest and protect the accused’s liberty.

Failure to follow this process may render the arrest illegal.

Conclusion

This Supreme Court decision enhances the constitutional protections towards protecting arbitrary arrests so that the fundamental rights of the accused are preserved. Furthermore, it delineates the authority of the courts to issue bail even when there are certain legal barriers, thus emphasising the need for due process and responsibility in the criminal justice system.

Join the conversation and stay informed! Visit the Jaagruk Bharat community page and be part of an active, engaged community, as we work day and night to bring information to your fingertips.